Help Support DVDdude.net by shopping at DVD Empire!
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants DVD Home DVD Archives DVD Reviews DVD Links DVD Contact
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, Rants and News Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants  

Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Technical Information

Studio: Fox Home Entertainment

Year of Theatrical Release: 2003

Disc Format: 3 single-sided, Dual Layer

Image Format: Anamorphic Widescreen

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Region Encoding: 1

Sound Format: Dolby Digital 5.1, DTS

Running Time: 133 minutes

Director: Brian Singer

Stars: Patrick Stewart, Hugh Jackman, Ian McKellen, Halle Berry, Fanke Janssen, Brian Cox, Alan Cumming, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos

MPAA Rating: PG-13

Disc Supplements:

  • Audio commentary with director Brian Singer and Cinematographer Newton Thomas Sigel
  • Audio commentary with producers Lauren Shuler Donner and Ralph Winter and writers Michael Dougherty, Dan Harris and David Hayter
  • Nightcrawler Attack: Interactive Multi-Angle Scene Study
  • Wolverine / Deathstrike FIght Rehersal
  • The Second Uncanny Issue of X-Men documentary
  • The Secret Origin of the X-Men featurette
  • Nightcrawler Reborn featurette
  • Introducing the Incredible NIghtcrawler featurette
  • FX2 Spectucular Visual Effects Guide featurette
  • Evolution in the Details featurette
  • United Colors of X featurette
  • Nightcrawler Stunt Rehersal featurette
  • Nightcrawler Time Lapse featurette
  • Requiem for Mutants featurette
  • Global Webcast Highlights featurette
  • 11 Deleted / Extended Scenes
  • Still Galleries
  • Theatrical Trailers
 

Quick Links:
Story
Video
Audio
Extras
Bottom Line

DVD review:
X2: X-Men United

X2: X-Men United
: : : STORY

If we were to go back in time about 10 years or so to the early 1990's, we would find ourselves in the midst of tons of speculation regarding a potential X-Men film. Who should play which character was the subject of a lot of fan debates, but above all of that was the simple, overriding fact that it was just plain impossible to effectively realize the mutant powers on screen. Everyone wanted the film, but no one ever seriously thought they would get made (or if they did, that they'd be any good).

So it was with no small amount of surprise that Hollywood did, in fact, get a film made, but that they also produced something that was quite good. Yes, certain elements had changed to accomodate the new medium of film, but the changes didn't detract from the overall intent of the X-Men mythos.

And the debate raged again, this time about the sequel. Given the success of the first film, a follow up was inevitable, but could it be any good or was the first try a fluke?

Amazingly enough, X-2: X-Men United is not only a better film than the first (admittedly, only slightly), but unlike many sequels, it adds to the richness of the world created in the first X-Men. X-2 isn't weighed down by the necessity of the "origin story," where it must introduce all of the main characters and what they can do. Even though the first film handled the origins well, it still slowed the film down a bit. X-2 assumes we've seen the first film and it just dives right in. We're given some brief backstory on the new characters, but for the most part the film doesn't stop to wait for straggling audience members to catch up.

In the first film, a Mutant Registration Act was narrowly avoided. This act would have required all mutants to register themselves and their powers, similar to the way gun owners must register their weapons. Persumably, the registration was going to be used as a means to regulate and control the mutant, which begged the question of what exactly would be done to mutant children that the goverment felt were too dangerous.

X-2 opens with a sequence that is absolutely astonishing and perhaps one of the best displays of super powers yet put on screen. This sequence involves a mutant named Kurt Wagner (Alan Cumming), who sometimes goes by the name Nightcrawler, and an attack on the White House. Wagner is a blue mutant with a prehensile tale and the ability to teleport instantly. He has honed this ability to the point where he can use it in combat. When fighting, Wagner seems to be in many places all at once and by the time he's punched or kicked an opponent, he's already teleported away before they have a chance to react. Wagner seems on a mission to kill the President and only a lucky shot to the mutant's arm saves the day.

Following the attack, General William Stryker (Brian Cox), a man with a personal hatred for mutants, attempts to gain new support for the Registration Act. In fact, he wants to take it a step further and actually conduct raids on known mutant locations. His first target, Xavier's (Patrick Stewart) mutant school. He receives permission for his raid and promptly attacks the school, successfully capturing a handful of mutants before Wolverine (Hugh Jackman), Rogue (Anna Paquin), Iceman (Shawn Ashmore) and Pyro (Aaron Stanford) assist most of the mutants in escaping.

Meanwhile, Magneto (Ian McKellen) is still imprisoned in his plastic shell and his most loyal henchman (henchwoman?) Mystique (Rebecca Romijn-Stamos) is plotting a way to set him free. Magneto is still at odds with Xavier. The two still share a desire for mutant prosperity, but Magneto believes that this will only come if the mutants are willing to rise up against the humans. Mystique succeeds in smuggling some metal into Magneto (in a most interesting way, I might add), allowing him to escape his prison.

Stryker's attack on the school has scattered the X-Men, but not before they learn that Stryker has found a way to control the mutants. In fact, it was Stryker's drug that forced Kurt Wagner to attack the White House. Stryker's intent is nothing short of the complete irradication of all mutants and this new threat creates an uneasy alliance between Magneto and the X-Men.

The obvious parallel to the X-Men stories is that of racial prejudice, but there are other social themes tucked in here and there as well. For instance, one key scene features Bobby Drake, or Iceman, revealing his powers to his parents. This "coming out" scene very obviously mimics homosexuality. Yet even such blatant allegory isn't handled in a preaching or heavy-handed tone. Bobby's mother naively asks if her son can simply just stop being a mutant, a poingantly funny moment.

The film doesn't make the mistake of suggesting that there are easy answers to either the fictional prejudice in the film or the real life prejudice the film plays off of. Yes, the characters wish we could all just "get along," but wisely also shows that we can't -- at least not without a significant struggle.

This is all pretty weighty stuff for what is essenitally just a summer action movie. The fact that the film manages to be entertaining on the level of pure action while still incorporating though-provoking themes suggests that such movies don't have to only be about explosions and fight scenes.

If there are any flaws with the film at all it's that X2 almost seems more like a middle story than a complete entity in and of itself. You must have seen the first film to understand some elements of this one and many of the plot points and the ending suggest that this is only a small part of a bigger picture. Word has it that a third X-Men outing is being planned. If this is true, hopefully it will settle some of the issues that were only started in this film.

:::back to top

: : : VIDEO

It is very difficult (and, I'm sure, just a bit boring) to describe the technical aspects of a disc when there are really no significant problems to be found. X2 is, quite simply, an excellent transfer. Colors are bright and solid, contrasts, black levels and shadow details are nearly perfect, and there isn't a spot of compression problems to be found. The only thing that prevents this disc from getting a perfect score in the video department is the overuse of edge enhancement.

:::back to top

: : : AUDIO

Wow. The audio on this disc is simply astonishing. It's reasonable to expect a certain level of sound quality from an action film, so it generally takes something really special to surpise a reviewer. X2 definitely delivers. Both the Dolby Digital and the DTS tracks offer a completely enveloping sound environment. Front to back and left to right panning is smooth and transparent. Both tracks offer wide dynamic range, particularly with the bass response, which is of earthquake proportions. This disc provides a great sound experience no matter which flavor you go with.

:::back to top

: : : EXTRAS

Fox has done a decent job of providing a solid special edition for X2, so hopefully consumers won't be faced with an X2.5 purchasing dilema here in a few months.

First up on disc one are two feature length audio commentaries. The first track features director Brian Singer and cinematographer Newton Thomas Sigel (credited as Tom Sigel on the actual disc). This track is a bit technical and subdued, but I do have to say that Tom Sigel has one of the dryest senses of humor I've heard. He tosses in the occasional deadpan line and if you aren't paying careful enough attention you might take him seriously. For those who can't get enough X-Men, there are a few vague hints at sequels.

Track two features producers Lauren Shuler Donner and Ralph Winter, and writers Michael Dougherty, Dan Harris and David Hayter. This is a somewhat uneven track, with many moments of silence followed by rapid bursts of everyone talking. When these guys do speak up they do a decent job of talking about the film and most of their comments compliment elements from the first commentary. However, I did notice one or two contradictions, for instance, Singer and Sigel mention finding Magneto's plastic prison in storage, but this second track talks about having to completely rebuild the set.

Disc 2 offers up a hefty array of featurettes. There are so many, in fact, that I couldn't possibly discuss them all in-depth, so I'll try to hit the highlights. One thing I can say about this disc as a whole is that there really isn't a lot of fluff here. Yes, a couple of the featurettes are a little on the promotional side, but nothing too heavy-handed or EPK-ish.

First up is an hour long documentary called The Second Uncanny Issue of X-Men: The Ultimate Making-Of Documentary. Easily the best of disc 2's features, this documentary does a decent job of covering the creation of the sequel from start to finish. This is probably one of the better DVD documentaries.

Nightcrawler Attack: Multi-Angle Study and Wolverine / Deathstrike Fight Rehearsal both take a closer look at two of the film's more spectacular fight scenes.

One of my favorite featurettes could almost be considered a throw-away. Nightcrawler Time Lapse runs only about 4 minutes, but is very cool. A lot of featurettes hint at the process of applying complex makeup effects, but they really don't (and can't) show the entire process that an actor must endure. Well, this remedies that problem. Time lapse photography shows us Alan Cumming's entire ordeal in the makeup chair and everything he had to endure is simply amazing. This is one of the more unique and fun featurettes I've seen in a long time.

The remaining featurettes (all listed in the Technical Information column) are fairly standard stuff about effects, costuming, stunts and so forth, but as I've said, they are all very well done and nicely presented. One thing I would like to mention is that when you've watched enough of these things, you begin to recognize certain behind-the-scenes crew members. For instance, Terry Notary, the film's movement coach, is a memorable and interesting character, who was featured quite extensively on the Planet of the Apes disc teaching the actors how to find their inner ape.

You'll find 11 deleted and extended scenes, some of which were obviously cut to preserve the film's rating (for example, a scene where Wolvering goes a little too over-the-edge while killing one of Stryker's men). I think that the final theatrical cut of the film is pretty decent, so these scenes are a mild curiosity, but wouldn't have really added too much more to the story.

Finally, you'll find Still Galleries and Theatrical Trailers.

:::back to top

: : : BOTTOM LINE

The first film's main deficiency was a lack of action (for a superhero movie). X-Men 2 more than corrects that problem, but it doesn't spare character development in the process. This is a more satisfying film, but it also leaves a lot of areas for the story to continue. If this level of quality can be maintained (or even improved upon), then this could be a very successful franchise. Certainly we aren't dealing with high art, but X-Men does provide good, solid entertainment.

:::back to top

: : : MOVIE
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : VIDEO
   
   
   
   
   
4.5 / 5
: : : AUDIO
   
   
   
   
   
5 / 5
: : : EXTRAS
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : FAMILY FRIENDLY
   
   
   
   
   
2.5 / 5
X-Men 2 is quite a bit more violent than the first film, so caution should be used regarding letting the little kids watch it. However, like the first film, there is a solid message of tolerance that helps to balance out the action.
: : : OVERALL
   
   
   
   
   
4.5 / 5

-- By Robert Wurth. Copyright © 2003.


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Most Recent DVD Reviews:

Firefly, the complete series

Enemy of the State: Special Edition

American Psycho: Killer Collector's Edition

Theater review: Superman Returns

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Rent: Special Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Buller...Bueller...Bueller Edition

Saw II

Saw

Broken

They Shoot Movies, Don't They?

The Island

Serenity

The Dukes of Hazzard (unrated)

Silverado: Gift Set

Unleashed (Unrated)

Robots

War of the Worlds: Limited Edition

Hostage

Sky High

Almost Normal


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants
Reviews

# | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X-Y-Z

 



Home | Archives | Reviews | News and Rants | Contact and Links
 

All reviews, articles and graphics pertaining to the layout of this website is Copyright © 2002, 2003 by Robert Wurth. Images, character names, or other assets associated with specific films are trademarked and/or Copyright by their respective companies/studios. Materials are used on this site for review purposes only and Deranged Video Dude and Robert Wurth makes no ownership claims to said materials. Contents of this site may not be reproduced in part or in whole without express written permission.

Website designed by Zuiun.com


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants