Help Support DVDdude.net by shopping at DVD Empire!
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants DVD Home DVD Archives DVD Reviews DVD Links DVD Contact
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, Rants and News Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants  

Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Technical Information

Studio: Paramount Home Video

Year of Theatrical Release: 1979

Disc Format: 1 single-sided, Dual Layer; 1 single-sided, single layer

Image Format: Anamorphic (16x9 enhanced)

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Region Encoding: 1

Sound Format: Dolby Digital 5.1, Dolby Digital 2.0 (Pro Logic)

Running Time: 136 minutes

Director: Robert Wise

Stars: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, DeForest Kelley

MPAA Rating: PG

Disc Supplements:

  • Audio Commentary by director Robert Wise, photographic effects director Douglas Trumbull, effects supervisor John Dykstra, composter Jerry Goldsmith, actor Stephen Collins.
  • Text fact commentary by Michael Okuda.
  • 3 Documentary featurettes: Phase II: The Lost Enterprise, A Bold New Enterprise, Redirecting the Future.
  • Teaser trailers, theatrical trailers and TV spots.
  • 5 additional scenes (from 1978 version).
  • 11 additional scenes (from 1983 version).
  • Storyboard archive
 

Quick Links:
Story
Video
Audio
Extras
Bottom Line

Star Trek: The Motion Picture Dirctor's Edition

Star Trek: The Motion Picture Director's Edition
: : : STORY

What a crazy life Star Trek has had.

When the series was first conceived, it had opposition from the studio. Changes were made and a pilot was eventually aired. Even after that, however, things did not go smoothly. It's been well-documented that the only thing the kept the show on the air was the enormous support from fans. Even then, Star Trek couldn't be saved and it was canceled in its third season.

Not wanted to just let the show die, syndication was considered, but even then there were troubles. The rule was that a show had to have 100 episodes before it could be syndicated. Star Trek had only 78 episodes (79 if you count the unaired pilot). The rule was bent and the show went on to become immensely more popular in syndication than it was originally.

Years later, when Paramount was considering starting their own network, they wanted to develop a new Star Trek series as the flagship show. Amazingly enough, Gene Roddenberry had to be convinced. While he still loved Star Trek, he wanted to move on. In the end, though, he signed up and a new show was conceived, called Star Trek: Phase II.

As the scope of the project grew, Paramount's hopes for a new network faltered and eventually died out entirely. Not giving up on what they considered a bankable franchise, they gave the green light for Phase II to be redeveloped as a feature film.

In 1979, Star Trek: The Motion Picture hit theaters...and many filmgoers promptly said, "huh?"

The film turned out to be well over 2 hours long and consisted of far too many scenes of actors staring off screen in amazement and of too many pondering shots of starships and shapeless clouds.

Somewhere along the way someone forgot there was a story to tell and the movie degenerated into little more than eye candy. Take for instance a scene early on in the film when Admiral Kirk (William Shatner) and Mr. Scott (James Doohan) are shuttling over to the newly refit Enterprise. Granted, this is the first time audiences have been treated to what the ship should really look like, but scene winds up being little more than well over 5 minutes of explorations into how to photograph a model. We spend so much time flying around the back and sides of the ship that by the time we get to the front view "money shot," the sense of awe has been replaced with a feeling of relief that now we can get on with the story.

The entire film is like this. Yes, there is something to be said for taking the time to experience all of the sights in a film like this, but there must be a careful balance. Equally important is the plot and the sense of urgency that we are supposed to feel from it. Yet all urgency is lost because any time something happens, rather than take action, all the crew (and camera) does is stand around and look at it.

This is a shame because trim a half hour or more out of the film and the plot would really be interesting. As the film opens, a trio of Klingon ships are approaching a huge, mysterious cloud that seems to have a gigantic space craft at its center. Being Klingons, their first reaction is naturally to shoot at it. Not only do they fail to have any effect, but the alien ship fires a weapon at the Klingons that seems to digitize them into its database.

Back on Earth we meet James Kirk, who has been promoted to Admiral since the days of the original 5-year mission. Not only was their mission a success, but the Enterprise has been adopted as the flagship of the Federation and has been completely refit and updated. Unfortunately, Kirk will no longer be at the helm.

The Federation learns that this alien spacecraft is heading right for Earth and the not-quite finished Enterprise is the only ship close enough. Kirk sees this as his chance to get back his command.

Meanwhile, on Vulcan, Spock (Leonard Nimoy) is striving to achieve Kolinahr, a state that will purge all emotion from his mind. His training is interrupted when he experiences a telepathic link with the alien ship. Not able to complete Kolinahr, he leaves Vulcan.

This allows the entire original crew to be reunited in a mission to discover what this alien ship is and why it's heading for Earth, destroying (digitizing) everything in its path.

A subplot in the film involves Admiral Kirk butting heads with Captain/Commander Will Decker (Stephen Collins). Decker is set to take the helm of the Enterprise when Kirk steps in to handle the new threat. Kirk is experienced and knows the crew, but Decker has been through the entire refit of the ship and knows it in and out.

I have to be honest in saying that Star Trek: The Motion Picture bored me when it first came out. After the brilliant The Wrath of Khan was released, I truly despised it. However, time has a way of changing perspectives. Given some of the other Trek films that have been released and the way this one fits into the grand scheme of things, I have to say that it really isn't all that bad. As I mentioned above, its primary failing is one of pacing. Tighten things up and it has the potential to be one of the better films of the series.

The release of the DVD, a director's edition no less, offered up just the chance to fix the pacing. Unfortunately, rather than tighten the film, even more was added to it. The running time now is actually longer than the original release! Granted, none of the new scenes take away from the film and some are genuinely worthwhile, but the movie remains dangerously on this side of boring.

Still, a stellar job has been done of bringing the film to DVD. Paramount really spared no expense in getting this production done. Not only did they allow director Robert Wise the chance to put together his own cut of the film, but they allowed for the expense of cleaning up and fixing some of the effects work. The interesting thing about the new effects is how seamlessly they fit into the film. Foundation Imaging really outdid themselves by painstakingly matching grain and dust elements in the original print. The idea wasn't to create effects by today's standards, but rather to recreate the sorts of effects that could have been done back then, but that couldn't be completed to to time or budget constraints. The results are wonderful and, for the most part, as seamless as intended.

:::back to top

: : : VIDEO

The picture on the disc isn't perfect, but that's not any fault of the DVD. Instead, the failings are due to the poor quality of the source material. Effects compositing back then often permanently imbedded dust into the film. This was simply the nature of the beast. Age is probably also a factor here. Still, Paramount took care the ensure that the picture looks as good as possible. Flaws aside, this is undoubtedly the best the film has ever looked on a home video format. I have to say, though, that I was a bit surprised with the decision to NOT clean up the print. At one point, someone at Foundation Imaging mentions how difficult it was to match the dust and grain in the new effects and I'm thinking, "so why not just digitally remove the dust and grain from the original material?" Oh well. The picture is still great -- for this film. The colors are brighter than ever before and the contrasts and black levels are impressive. There were no digital artifacts and, thankfully, little to no edge enhancement.

:::back to top

: : : AUDIO

The sound has been completely remixed for this release. Many complain when studios make the decision to update a sound mix, but in this case it's justified. The sound was one of the elements that was never fully completely for the films initial release. For this reason, many scenes quite simply lacked any sound but the musical score. This was definitely not the intent and now the problem has been fixed and updated. Good use is made of the surround field and the overall dynamic range is very impressive. Best yet, Jerry Goldsmith's score (still the best out of the entire Star Trek franchise) sounds better than ever. Also of note is that the film initially contained a 2-minute overture featuring a starfield and Goldsmith's music. This has been restored to the beginning of the film and is a nice touch.

:::back to top

: : : EXTRAS

Now, in terms of extras, this disc is loaded. Paramount has turned this into a 2-disc special edition and word has it that the other Trek films are going to be revisited with this treatment. All I can say is that I can't wait.

First up in the extras department is a feature length commentary on disc one. This track is a compilation of comments by Robert Wise, Jerry Goldsmith , effects director Douglas Trumbull, visual effects guru John Dykstra and actor Stephen Collins. That many participants guarantees that there will be few areas of silence in the track, but the tradeoff is any real focus to the commentary. Still, there are some good things to be learned here and a lot of information about the troubles involved in developing Trek as a second series and then turning that project into a feature film.

Next up is a feature length subtitle option of factoids presented by Michael Okuda (if you're a true fan, you may recognize him as the co-author of the Star Trek Encyclopedia). This guy probably knows more about Star Trek than anyone else and this track is immensely fun to read. Even if you aren't a hardcore Trek fan, you'll likely find it fun to read.

Disc two's main feature is a series of featurettes that somewhat tell the tale of the life of this film. Phase II: The Lost Enterprise tells the story beginning at the end of the original series' television run. It details some of the fan support as well as the problems in trying to generate a new Star Trek series. Plans for Phase II fizzled when Paramount's proposed new network failed to happen. This is about here the featurette ends.

A Bold New Enterprise picks up the tale as efforts were shifted to turn Star Trek into a big budget feature film. Quite a bit is covered in this featurette, but the overall theme seems to be one of compromise. The crew was under such a tight deadline that there were serious concerns about whether or not everything would get finished (which it didn't). Former Paramount Exec. Jeffrey Katzenberg describes his days of non-stop driving from location to location in an effort to make sure everyone was on track and keep them all excited about working on the project. You get the feeling that he genuinely remembers a sense of pure desperation from that time in his life.

Finally, Redirecting The Future details the production of this director's edition. This is probably the least interesting of the featurettes to anyone not interested in the technical aspects of special effects work.

This disc includes what may be the most extensive selection of deleted scenes I've ever seen. First of all, the director's cut trims and reworks a couple of scenes. All of these are included as they originally appeared and all are presented in anamorphic widescreen. Also, the 1983 television version of the film featured an even longer cut of the film (which brought the running time to nearly 3 hours). All of these scenes are included. Finally, a set of outtakes features some screentests for scenes that were planned, but never fully realized.

Rounding things out are a storyboard archive, theatrical and teaser trailers and TV spots. An interesting thing about the TV spots is that they were narrated by Orson Welles. Funny, that

:::back to top

: : : BOTTOM LINE

So, this isn't my favorite Trek film, but it isn't my least favorite either (The Final Frontier, anyone?). Despite my belief that it's overly long, I still think The Motion Picture has a good story to tell. This DVD release is certainly cool and I'll look forward to more like this from Paramount.

:::back to top

: : : MOVIE
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
: : : VIDEO
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
: : : AUDIO
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : EXTRAS
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : FAMILY FRIENDLY
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
Star Trek: The Motion Picture was originally released with a G rating. This has since been updated to a PG, but the film is still pretty safe for the whole family. If anything, the slow pace may be the only deterrent to the younger ones.
: : : OVERALL
   
   
   
   
   
3 / 5

-- By Robert Wurth. Copyright © 2003.


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Most Recent DVD Reviews:

Firefly, the complete series

Enemy of the State: Special Edition

American Psycho: Killer Collector's Edition

Theater review: Superman Returns

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Rent: Special Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Buller...Bueller...Bueller Edition

Saw II

Saw

Broken

They Shoot Movies, Don't They?

The Island

Serenity

The Dukes of Hazzard (unrated)

Silverado: Gift Set

Unleashed (Unrated)

Robots

War of the Worlds: Limited Edition

Hostage

Sky High

Almost Normal


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants
Reviews

# | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X-Y-Z

 



Home | Archives | Reviews | News and Rants | Contact and Links
 

All reviews, articles and graphics pertaining to the layout of this website is Copyright © 2002, 2003 by Robert Wurth. Images, character names, or other assets associated with specific films are trademarked and/or Copyright by their respective companies/studios. Materials are used on this site for review purposes only and Deranged Video Dude and Robert Wurth makes no ownership claims to said materials. Contents of this site may not be reproduced in part or in whole without express written permission.

Website designed by Zuiun.com


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants