Help Support DVDdude.net by shopping at DVD Empire!
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants DVD Home DVD Archives DVD Reviews DVD Links DVD Contact
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, Rants and News Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants  

Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Technical Information

Studio: Paramount Home Entertainment

Year of Theatrical Release: N/A

Disc Format: 1 single-sided, Dual Layer

Image Format: Full Frame

Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1

Region Encoding: 1

Sound Format: Dolby Digital 5.1, Dolby Digital 2.0 (pro logic)

Running Time: Approximately 45 minutes per episode

Director: Various

Stars: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, DeForest Kelley

MPAA Rating: NR

Disc Supplements:

  • Episode Trailers
  • Text commentary on selected episodes
  • Birth of a Timeless Legacy featurette
  • Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner featurette
  • To Boldy Go...Season 1 featurette
  • Reflections on Spock featurette
  • Sci-Fi Visionaries featurette
  • Production Stills gallery
 

Quick Links:
Story
Video
Audio
Extras
Bottom Line

DVD Review:
Star Trek - The Original Series, Season 1

Star Trek Season 1
: : : STORY

At the risk of compromising my integrity in the eyes of my following, I have to admit that when I was a little kid, I didn't really like Star Trek. At about the age of 6 I had been introduced to Star Wars and to my inexperienced eyes, Star Trek just looked cheap by comparison.

The a funny thing happend about the time I reached my early to mid-teens. I actually began to pay attention to the stories. Suddenly, Star Trek was fresh and it was all because of the writing. To say that I became hooked on the exploits of Captain Kirk (William Shatner), Mr. Spock (Leonard Nimoy), Dr. McCoy (DeForest Kelley) and the rest of the crew of the Starship Enterprise would be an understatement.

I would imagine that those trying to watch the show for the first time today would be shocked by the blatant cliches in episode after episode. What one must remember is that these are cliches only because Star Trek made them cliches. This is where it all began. Star Trek isn't the beginning of science fiction, mind you, but it was the beginning of serious science fiction for the masses.

I think what made the series great is that, although special effects were a major part of the show, Gene Roddenberry and his team knew that they could never create effects as perfect as they envisioned them. Therefore, they didn't rely on them. Yes, many shots are ridiculously low quality. Yes, all of the planets look like the same soundstage covered in foam rocks. But because the writing was so solid and the storytelling was so engaging, the effects just don't matter. Our minds are willing to simply accept it and fill in the details.

Paramount made an odd decision to release Star Trek as individual packages, so I was excited to learn that they were going to put the whole series into season box sets. Having it all together in three box sets not only saves on shelf space, but also illustrates just how much quality was packed into a short 3 season run.

While there are gems all throughout the run of the series, it could be argued that season 1 contains some of very best Star Trek had to offer. My personal choice for the best in season 1 is Space Seed. Fans will recognize this as the introduction of Khan (Ricardo Montalban), who is not only James T. Kirks greatest adversary, but after his appearance in Star Trek II, perhaps one of the greatest villains of all time.

Season 1 also contains The City on the Edge of Forever, which also ranks high as a fan favorite, and even won the show an award from the Writers Guild of America. The first season also played around with the notion of good and evil and the capacity for both in everyone with the episodes Naked Time and The Enemy Within. This is a concept the series would return to many times.

Star Trek also routinely used its science fiction backdrop as a canvas for social commentary on everything from drug use, to prejudice, to government control. Some episodes (such as Balance of Terror, which touches on the fear of prejudice) handle this much better than others (like Miri, which is a thinly veiled attack on the oppression of the youth culture).

Above all, however, Star Trek was a brilliant achievement and season 1 was strong right out of the gate, a feat none of its predecessors have managed.

:::back to top

: : : VIDEO

Let's face it, short of digitally recreating the series, there is just no way that Star Trek is going to look anywhere near as good as any modern production. However, having said that, some extensive work has been done to clean up and digitally restore the series. Much of the dust and scratches that you will be used to seeing on the televised reruns are gone. The colors are once again crisp and vibrant and I would venture to say that the show now looks better than it ever has.

I didn't really notice any flaws in the digital presentation other than some slight digital noise here and there. Edge enhancement seems to be at a minimum.

Overall, the first season looks great.

:::back to top

: : : AUDIO

Obviously, Star Trek was originally presented in mono sound for television broadcast. For the remastering, this mix was upgraded to 5.1. This should best be considered an interpretation of what the soundtrack might have been, had the technology been available. The surround information isn't as natural sounding as a true 5.1 mix, but it is still quite good. Some work has been done to enhance the overall dynamic range, creating a much fuller sound experience. Also, a lot of the hissing and audio inconsistencies have been eliminated, making this the best the original series has ever sounded.

:::back to top

: : : EXTRAS

Kicking things off in the extras department are the preview trailers for each episode. These were previously available on Paramount's first release of the series.

Next up are text commentary tracks by Trek historians Michael and Denise Okuda. Only 4 episodes receive a commentary: Where No Man Has Gone Before, The Menagerie Part 1, The Menagerie Part 2, and The Conscience Of The King. It's possible that no other two people on this planet know more about Star Trek than these two, and they are able to provide some interesting insight into these selected episodes.

The bulk of the remaining extras take the form of 5 featurettes. The first is The Birst of a Timeless Legacy, which runs about 25 minutes and takes a look at out the series came to be (or rather almost didnt).

Next is perhaps the strangest feature, called Life Beyond Star Trek: William Shatner. At about 10 minutes, there is really very little here that has anything to do with with Star Trek. Instead, Shatner talks a lot about horses.

To Boldy Go...Season 1 is a retrospective of some of the season's best episodes It runs about 20 minutes and discusses some of the production issues involved with the creation of these timeless classics.

Much better than Shatner's segment is Leonard Nimoy's Reflections on Spock. Nimoy has an interesting history with this character. At one point in his career, he wrote a book called I Am Not Spock, in which he tried to understand and separate himself from the Spock character. He followed his up later with a sequel, I Am Spock. Here, he talks about his decision to write these books and the impact this iconic character has had on his life.

Sci-Fi Visionaries runs nearly 20 minutes and takes look at the many famous writers who contributed to Star Trek, including Harlan Ellison, D. C. Fontanta and Gene Coon.

Finishing things off for this set is a production stills gallery and a few Easter Egg features.

Star Trek fans will certainly wish that this set had a little more to offer than this, but what is here is presented well. Are there more materials out there? Certainly. Perhaps Paramount is saving some of this for the shorter 3rd season. But I can only review what is here.

:::back to top

: : : BOTTOM LINE

Star Trek is an undeniable classic and it looks better than ever on DVD. Even though the extras are a bit lacking, there is still some interesting stuff here and besides, the episodes are the real reason to buy this set.

:::back to top

: : : MOVIE
   
   
   
   
   
5 / 5
: : : VIDEO
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
: : : AUDIO
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
: : : EXTRAS
   
   
   
   
   
3 / 5
: : : FAMILY FRIENDLY
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
Star Trek deals with some mature themes, but it does so in such a television-friendly way that nearly the entire series is appropriate for the entire family.
: : : OVERALL
   
   
   
   
   
4.5 / 5

-- By Robert Wurth. Copyright © 2004.


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Most Recent DVD Reviews:

Firefly, the complete series

Enemy of the State: Special Edition

American Psycho: Killer Collector's Edition

Theater review: Superman Returns

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Rent: Special Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Buller...Bueller...Bueller Edition

Saw II

Saw

Broken

They Shoot Movies, Don't They?

The Island

Serenity

The Dukes of Hazzard (unrated)

Silverado: Gift Set

Unleashed (Unrated)

Robots

War of the Worlds: Limited Edition

Hostage

Sky High

Almost Normal


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants
Reviews

# | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X-Y-Z

 



Home | Archives | Reviews | News and Rants | Contact and Links
 

All reviews, articles and graphics pertaining to the layout of this website is Copyright © 2002, 2003 by Robert Wurth. Images, character names, or other assets associated with specific films are trademarked and/or Copyright by their respective companies/studios. Materials are used on this site for review purposes only and Deranged Video Dude and Robert Wurth makes no ownership claims to said materials. Contents of this site may not be reproduced in part or in whole without express written permission.

Website designed by Zuiun.com


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants