Help Support DVDdude.net by shopping at DVD Empire!
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants DVD Home DVD Archives DVD Reviews DVD Links DVD Contact
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, Rants and News Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants  

Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Technical Information

Studio: Touchstone Home Video

Year of Theatrical Release: 2001

Disc Format: 2 single-sided, Dual Layer

Image Format: Anamorphic (16x9 enhanced)

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Region Encoding: 1

Sound Format: DTS, Dolby Digital 5.1, Dolby Digital 2.0 Headphone Track

Running Time: 183 minutes

Director: Michael Bay

Stars: Ben Afleck, Kate Beckinsale, Cuba Gooding, Jr., Josh Hartnett

MPAA Rating: PG-13

Disc Supplements:

  • Journey to the Screen: The Making of Pearl Harbor documentary.
  • Unsung Heroes History Channel documentary.
  • Faith Hill music video.
  • Theatrical and teaser trailers.
 

Quick Links:
Story
Video
Audio
Extras
Bottom Line

Pearl Harbor

Pearl Harbor
: : : STORY

Let me just get this out of the way: Michael Bay is the worst mainstream director working in Hollywood today. Admittedly, some of his films have been mildly entertaining, but I assure you that it had nothing to do with the direction and everything to do with the actors involved (The Rock comes to mind).

Bay's directing and editing choices on Armageddon created a film that was only a couple of edits shy of being a slide show. Since that movie was overly long to begin with, I wasn't looking forward to that same style being used on something clocking in at just over three hours. Although Bay has reigned his quick cuts in slightly -- but only slightly -- for Pearl Harbor, the film still looks more like a music video than it does a feature film. And a music video is certainly not the tone one should strive for when tackling subject matter as serious as the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Fast editing itself isn't always a bad thing, but Bay's quick cuts seem to exist to hide the fact that there isn't a shred of originality or creativity to the way he sets up his shots and tells his stories. When you combine that with a script that is as bad as it is long, you're set for a wasted three hours of your life.

I'm fairly certain that this film was not intended as a comedy, and yet I haven't laughed as hard at a movie in quite a while. Every line of dialogue is performed (poorly, I might add, but I'll get to the acting in a bit) as though it were the most profound thing ever said. The trouble is that there is nothing profound about this movie. I thought Armageddon had some howlers, but this script makes that meteor flick sound like Shakespeare.

They say that a good actor can make you weep by just reading names out of the phone book. Perhaps that's yet another testament to how bad this script is. Some good and notable actors make appearances in Pearl Harbor, yet not a one of them turns in a performance above the level found in your average junior high school play. If anything, they seem to be as astonished at reading the horrible lines as we are at hearing them.

I think it's fairly safe to say that the lousy performances are Bay's fault. He is obviously far more concerned with picking out which filters will make his shots look the most like postcards than he is with anything resembling storytelling or acting. As long as his actors just stand there and look pretty, who cares what's coming out of their mouths?

Like other psuedo-historical films, such as Titanic and Saving Private Ryan, Pearl Harbor places fictional characters in the midst of real events. In this case, we follow two best friends, Rafe McCawley (Ben Afleck) and Danny Walker (Josh Hartnett) as they join the US Army Air Corp and eventually fall in love with the same woman (Kate Beckinsale). Oh, and at some point Pearl Harbor is attacked by the Japanese, but that event seems to take a back seat to the boring, contrived and trite love triangle.

Given that, to describe the film as being based on the events of December 7, 1941, would be a terrible disservice to history. Rather, this is the story of Pearl Harbor as told by someone who's only source of historical input comes from Hollywood and MTV. Facts seem to have been considered an optional ingredient -- they are included when convenient and cheerfully tossed out the rest of the time. Still, I could forgive some anachronisms or inaccuracies if the writing, acting and directing were strong enough to make up the difference. Instead, we are given a story that is an insult to the world regarding the attack on Pearl Harbor.

I won't fault anyone for liking this film, but if anyone out there thinks this is in some way an accurate representation of the Japanese attack, then they need to have their head examined -- or at the very least, switch off the TV and open up a history book. For one thing, the Japanese were motivated by far more than a fear of running out of oil, but you'd never know that from this script.

Now, if you're going to sit through a film mired in pure crap, then the film's remaining few bits of action better be sterling, right? Well, I can say that the action is best part of this film, and it's all truly spectacular, but extremely watered down. There were thousands of casualties at Pearl Harbor, yet this film shows very little of it. Even the hospital scenes are filtered through a blurry lens. It's as though Bay wanted to protect a precious PG-13 rating by sanitizing the war for us. I'm not saying that the film should have given us blood and guts strewn all over the screen, but if you're going to try to depict the horror of an event, then have the courage to show it without flinching away. Bay's interpretation of the attack manages to invest as much emotional impact in World War II as Microsoft's Combat Flight Simulator.

:::back to top

: : : VIDEO

Touchstone Home Video made the choice to spread the film over two discs so that they could maintain the best picture possible. In many ways, this seems to have been the right choice. Colors are vibrant and lifelike -- the dialog in the film may have been meaningless, but at least the actors look good saying it. Good contrast is exhibited throughout the transfer, with deep blacks that hold excellent detail. I couldn't spot anything in the way of digital artifacting and only very little grain. Most concerning about the picture, however, is the edge enhancement. When will studios get it through their heads that edge enhancement reduces picture quality rather than improves it? DVD doesn't need it. Period. All of the good elements in this transfer are taken down several notches by the over use of edge enhancement.

:::back to top

: : : AUDIO

Surprisingly, the audio side of this disc isn't quite as impressive as I expected. That isn't to say the tracks aren't good, because they are. I just expected a little more use of the surrounds. As is, there is decent dynamic range with solid, rumbling bass and clear highs. The surrounds are given some work, primarily during the action scenes, but as I said, I just thought they would have had slightly more of a workout. The dialog is rooted to the center stage and always distinct. Both a Dolby Digital and DTS track are included and I noticed little difference between the two.

Of note is the inclusion of a special Dolby Digital 2.0 Headphone Track. This mix is intended to optimize the sound, as you might guess, for listening on a pair of headphones. I tried this out by plugging into my laptop and I have to say that I was very impressed. Despite only having two speakers to work with, there was an amazing feeling of being enveloped in the sound. Granted, this isn't the same as full 5.1 sound, but is a very noticeable improvement over previous headphone experiences. Here's to hoping this feature turns up with more frequency.

:::back to top

: : : EXTRAS

Buena Vista has decided to be fairly blatant in their greed and have announced no less than three versions of this DVD, two of which are available now. This review is based on the two-disc 60th anniversary edition. Also out there is a boxed set that includes this same two-disc set and the National Geographic special Beyond The Movie: Pearl Harbor DVD. Finally, a three-disc director's edition will be released in 2002.

For this two-disc set we've been given a couple of extras, but nothing all that spectacular. First up is a documentary of the making of the film. Journey to the Screen: The Making of Pearl Harbor is just shy of being EPK fluff. There is some interesting stuff presented here and plenty of back-patting over what a great movie Pearl Harbor will be (they must not have actually finished reading the script at this point).

Next up is a History channel documentary called Unsung Heroes of Pearl Harbor. This piece is intended to be as much informative as anything else and yet contains more emotional impact than the entire film. There are several interviews with survivors as well as some newsreel footage.

Bay's films seem to inspire cheesy, uninspired songs and this is no exception, as proved by Faith Hill's There You'll Be music video. Ok, so she's nice to look at, but this is still a worthless song.

Finally, you'll find a promo for the National Geographic disc found in the box set and the theatrical and teaser trailers.

:::back to top

: : : BOTTOM LINE

So, after reading this, did you get the feeling that I didn't care for the film? I certainly hope so. Normally, when I dislike a film I recommend it as a rental on the off chance that someone out there may enjoy it. I just can't go there with this film. Quite simply, I wouldn't wish it on anyone. The only saving grace for this DVD is the ability to directly select the actual attack on Pearl Harbor, but even that is botched by Bay's desire to preserve the family-friendly rating. All in all, this is one to avoid at all costs. If you are bound and determined to inflict the pain of owning this disc on yourself, at least go for the three-disc edition, which offers up a little more in interesting extras.

:::back to top

: : : MOVIE
   
   
   
   
   
.5 / 5
: : : VIDEO
   
   
   
   
   
3 / 5
: : : AUDIO
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : EXTRAS
   
   
   
   
   
2.5 / 5
: : : FAMILY FRIENDLY
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
Realistically speaking, there isn't a whole lot here that's inappropriate for the family. However, you won't want to run the risk that they'll watch this and actually think it represents history.
: : : OVERALL
   
   
   
   
   
2 / 5

-- By Robert Wurth. Copyright © 2003.


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Most Recent DVD Reviews:

Firefly, the complete series

Enemy of the State: Special Edition

American Psycho: Killer Collector's Edition

Theater review: Superman Returns

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Rent: Special Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Buller...Bueller...Bueller Edition

Saw II

Saw

Broken

They Shoot Movies, Don't They?

The Island

Serenity

The Dukes of Hazzard (unrated)

Silverado: Gift Set

Unleashed (Unrated)

Robots

War of the Worlds: Limited Edition

Hostage

Sky High

Almost Normal


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants
Reviews

# | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X-Y-Z

 



Home | Archives | Reviews | News and Rants | Contact and Links
 

All reviews, articles and graphics pertaining to the layout of this website is Copyright © 2002, 2003 by Robert Wurth. Images, character names, or other assets associated with specific films are trademarked and/or Copyright by their respective companies/studios. Materials are used on this site for review purposes only and Deranged Video Dude and Robert Wurth makes no ownership claims to said materials. Contents of this site may not be reproduced in part or in whole without express written permission.

Website designed by Zuiun.com


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants