Help Support DVDdude.net by shopping at DVD Empire!
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants DVD Home DVD Archives DVD Reviews DVD Links DVD Contact
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants
Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, Rants and News Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews, News and Rants  

Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Technical Information

Studio: New Line Home Entertainment

Year of Theatrical Release: 2001

Disc Format: 2 single-sided, Dual Layer

Image Format: Anamorphic (16x9 enhanced)

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Region Encoding: 1

Sound Format: Dolby Digital 5.1 EX

Running Time: 178 minutes

Director: Peter Jackson

Stars: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Viggo Mortensen, Sean Astin, Cate Blanchett, Christopher Lee

MPAA Rating: PG-13

Disc Supplements:

  • Welcome to Middle Earth featurette
  • Quest for the Ring featurette
  • A Passage to Middle Earth featurette
  • 15 web vignettes
  • Preview of The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
  • Theatrical trailers and TV spots
  • Enya "May It Be" music video
  • Preview of Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers video game
  • Preview of the Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring extended edition DVD release
 

Quick Links:
Story
Video
Audio
Extras
Bottom Line

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings
: : : STORY

Who would have thought that a live action version of The Lord of the Rings could be brought to the big screen? More than that, would would have thought it would actually be any good? It's hard enough to bring a novel to life in the movies, but here is a series of books that is so well known, so loved, that the mere thought of creating a screenplay from them has daunted most. The books are too complex, they said.

Until recently, they were right.

It would never have been enough to get the story correct because so much of what makes The Lord of the Rings great is its visual texture. This may sound odd when talking about the written word, but J. R. R. Tolkien managed to create such distinct and detailed descriptions of his world that the novels have since shaped the very way we think a fantasy world should look. Every book, film and role-playing game since has been directly influenced by The Lord of the Rings.

I do not envy the battle director Peter Jackson must have gone through to get this project going. Just imagine the checklist of questions he had to answer: Can you create a race of little people? Not midgets or dwarfs, mind you, but actual small people? No problem. How about orcs, golems, dragons and other mystical creatures? Here you go. Can you find locations that don't look like some nature preserve, but can actually convince people they're looking at Middle Earth? Got it covered. How about translating the massive, epic trilogy of books into a trilogy of films -- and remain faithful to the story? Can do.

The man must have sounded insane.

Still, he managed to find a studio just as insane as he was in New Line and they gave him the go-ahead. Not only that, but it was decided to remove any doubt of the insanity of the project and allow Jackson to film all three chapters simultaneously. This would allow them to maintain a consistent visual look and pace.

So after much speculation, much hype, many uncertainties and a grueling production schedule, only one question really remained: Would the films be any good?

During the production of the films, Peter Jackson said that it was his hope that these three films would do for the fantasy genre what Star Wars did for science fiction. If this first installment is any indication, I think the trilogy has a good chance of doing just that.

After several stabs at the genre that range from astonishingly bad (Dungeons and Dragons) to entertaining, but mediocre (Willow), here at last is a film to define cinematic fantasy. Quite simply, The Lord of the Rings is nothing short of a triumph, a home run that is right on track to become a grand slam.

The first intallment, The Fellowship of the Rings, opens with a long exposition about the history of Middle Earth, particularly the One Ring and an epic battle to destroy it. We are briefly introduced to Bilbo Baggins' (Ian Holm) adventures from The Hobbit and the role he played in the rediscovery of the Ring. There is a definite danger is starting out a film with a long narration, but it works here and conveys some essential information that prevents having to slow down the film later.

From there we enter the Shire, where the Hobbits live. The famous wizard, Gandalf the Grey (Ian McKellen), has returned in time for Bilbo's birthday. Bilbo, who has not aged a day since aquiring the ring, has decided it is time for him to leave the Shire and finish his novel.

At the same time, the spirit of the evil wizard Sauron has returned and has dispatched agents, ring wraiths, to reclaim the ring. The wraiths are able to hone in the ring's location each time it is used. This spells bad news for the shire when Biblo uses the ring to make a dramatic exit from his party.

Bilbo entrusts the ring to his nephew, Frodo (Elijah Wood), and leaves the Shire for his new adventures. With the threat to the Shire imminent, Gandalf convinces Frodo to take the ring out of the Shire. This, of course, is the beginning of the great adventure for Frodo and his companions, Sam (Sean Astin), , Merry (Dominic Monighan) and Pippin (Billy Boyd).

Now, no real talk about The Fellowship of the Ring could take place without acknowledging the siginifcant differences between the film and the book. By very nature, the film needs to be faster paced and more dynamic. In fact, this is where the film has a chance to excell. The novels were always more about the characters than the action. In fact, the battles always seemed almost like an afterthought -- necessary to the story, but not necessary to describe in detail.

The medium of film gives us the opportunity to visualize the more kinetic elements of the tale. The trick is to display the great battles, but not at the expense of the story or characters. Peter Jackson manages to handle this task very well. While the characters aren't quite as realized as in the novels, they are still given plenty of depth and emotion. And if the characters seem at all cliched, you must keep in mind that these characters are what inspired the cliches.

There does seem to be something of a deliberation to the events as they unfold, as though the characters all know what awaits them. This lends a storyteller aspect to the film, as though this is a fable being handed down to us -- which, in a sense, is exactly what The Lord of the Rings is.

Jackson's direction is solid and the editing and cinematography are first-rate. Where other fantasy films seem like soundstage or backlot efforts, this film really looks and feels like Middle Earth. The effects work is top-notch, also adding to the feeling of realism. Many of the effects are right in your face, but some of the best, such as the creation of the Hobbits, is much more subtle and effective.

I have to admit that I was skeptical about this project. That skepticism was turned to astonishment and amazement when I actually saw the finished product. Will this film do for fantasy what Star Wars did for science fiction? I can't say. What I do know is that despite already knowing the story, this film managed to inspire a sense of wonder in me similar to what Lucas' 1977 epic inspires.

:::back to top

: : : VIDEO

Getting a film that is nearly three hours long to look good on a single disc is accomplishment enough. Getting a film that is nearly two hours long, filled with lots of action, smoke and fog and night scenes galore to look good on a single disc is nothing short of miraculous. It's obvious that a lot of care went into the production of this DVD. New Line spared not a single bit's worth of room to make The Fellowship of the Ring look as good as possible on a single disc.

To be perfectly fair, this is not a reference quality transfer, but it's very close. There is a rich, deep quality to the black levels, with fine detail and clarity in the shadows. The colors range from nearly muted, almost black and white in some scenes of rain and darkness, to lush, textured greens of the forests and plains and all of this is conveyed beautifully in the transfer. The film has a habit of going from virtual darkness to almost jarring and blinding brightness and this carries over perfectly on DVD, creating nearly the same experience in a darkened room as in the theater. Edge enhancement seems to be minimal to non-existent, which is always for the better. Really, the only problem to be found, and the only thing keeping this from reference quality, are some slight compression errors here and there. These artifacts are by no means distracting (if you're paying attention to the film rather than the quality of the transfer, you'll never notice them), but they are present and do bring the video score down just a bit.

As a side note, the upcoming extended edition will be spread over two discs. If the same level of care is put into it as in this release (and there's no reason to suspect otherwise), then that disc will be a new reference standard.

:::back to top

: : : AUDIO

The visuals of The Fellowship of the Ring are what people will remember, but the audio carries almost as much weight in the film and this, too, is represented well on the disc. This is a very atmospheric sound mix, where nearly every scene is bursting with life. Your surround speakers will certainly not be wasted here. Panning from left to right and front to back is very natural. Dialogue is anchored to the screen and always clear and intelligable. There is wide dynamic range, with airy highs and thundering lows. If the video portion of the disc contains slight flaws, the audio contains none. This is a Dolby Digital EX track that will make you forget that such a thing called DTS even exists.

:::back to top

: : : EXTRAS

Despite a 4-disc set to be released soon, New Line still saw fit to give us a true special edition release now -- although it's not the best special edition out there.

The main thing missing (and it's a forgivable omission, since Peter Jackson was unavailable while he finished up The Two Towers) is a feature length commentary. Ideally, we could have gotten a commentary on this film by someone else (some cast members, perhaps?) and the director's commentary on the longer cut. Hopefully someone at New Line will see this and keep it in mind for the remaining two films, rather than only giving us the commentaries on the 4-disc sets.

Still, there is some decent content here and some not-so-decent promotional fluff.

On the decent side are the 15 featurettes produced for the web. Each of these run only a couple of minutes. There isn't a whole lot in the way of content, but they are a fun look at some of the hype that was generated for the film. These are very similar to the featurettes created for Star Wars that appears on the Star Wars website.

Also on the good side are the theatrical trailer, teaser and television promos. There's also a pretty cool 11-minute look a the next film, The Two Towers. Finally, the Enya music video for May It Be is offered. It's well produced and will be appreciated by fans of Enya's music.

Now, on the not-so-decent side are a series of three so-called behind-the-scenes features. There is Welcome to Middle Earth, Quest for the Ring and Passage to Middle Earth. Each is longer than the last and each is more boring than the last. Perhaps that's not entirely fair, however these features really are little more than glorified Electronic Press Kits. There is a lot of hype and promotion going on here and very little real substance about the making of the film.

Finally, there is a game demo that, like most such demos winding up on DVD, is pretty worthless. And, just to tease and taunt, New Line decided to include a preview of the upcoming extended edition -- and this marks a first: a DVD promoting the release of another DVD release of the same film.

So, the question is whether to buy this edition or wait until the extended version is released? Here are some things to consider: The extended edition will not contain the theatrical release of the film, so if you like the film the way it is, this version is your only option. The extra content in this version will, for the most part, not be repeated in the extended edition, so completionists will need both. And finally, if special edition content is only mildly appealing to you, then a 4-disc set is only going to be a waste of money.

:::back to top

: : : BOTTOM LINE

Considered on its own merits (which is the only way to consider it fairly), this is a very respectable release of a great film. It looks and sounds fantastic and has a mixed bag of extra content. Despite the forthcoming extended edition, I can say that this disc is worth recommendation.

:::back to top

: : : MOVIE
   
   
   
   
   
4.5 / 5
: : : VIDEO
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5
: : : AUDIO
   
   
   
   
   
5 / 5
: : : EXTRAS
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
: : : FAMILY FRIENDLY
   
   
   
   
   
3.5 / 5
There are some scary and intense scenes, but for the most part, none of the content is too violent -- not a lot of blood and guts, all things considered -- and there is certainly no sex or foul language. Supervision is a good idea, but there's no reason most of the family can't enjoy it.
: : : OVERALL
   
   
   
   
   
4 / 5

-- By Robert Wurth. Copyright © 2003.


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants

Most Recent DVD Reviews:

Firefly, the complete series

Enemy of the State: Special Edition

American Psycho: Killer Collector's Edition

Theater review: Superman Returns

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Rent: Special Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Buller...Bueller...Bueller Edition

Saw II

Saw

Broken

They Shoot Movies, Don't They?

The Island

Serenity

The Dukes of Hazzard (unrated)

Silverado: Gift Set

Unleashed (Unrated)

Robots

War of the Worlds: Limited Edition

Hostage

Sky High

Almost Normal


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants
Reviews

# | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X-Y-Z

 



Home | Archives | Reviews | News and Rants | Contact and Links
 

All reviews, articles and graphics pertaining to the layout of this website is Copyright © 2002, 2003 by Robert Wurth. Images, character names, or other assets associated with specific films are trademarked and/or Copyright by their respective companies/studios. Materials are used on this site for review purposes only and Deranged Video Dude and Robert Wurth makes no ownership claims to said materials. Contents of this site may not be reproduced in part or in whole without express written permission.

Website designed by Zuiun.com


Deranged Video Dude: DVD Reviews and Rants