It's no secret that Braveheart has been one
of the most eagerly anticipated DVDs ever since the format was
introduced. A quick search of the alt.video.dvd archives will
reveal hundreds of posts begging, pleading, demanding and asking
for this title. Well, it's finally here and the burning question
is: Does it live up to expectations?
Braveheart is an historical epic, that odd
Hollywood beast that attempts to spin real events into an entertaining
format. It tells the tale of William Wallace and his efforts
to free Scotland from the rule of England. However, simply because
this movie is based upon real events doesn't mean the movie
remains true to those events. If you want historical accuracy
(or at least what passes for it), go watch a documentary or
read a history book. While there are true-to-life elements in
the film, Braveheart is first and foremost a product meant to
entertain. In his commentary track, Gibson makes no apologies
for any inaccuracies and many of them were conscious choices.
I am by no means finding fault with the choices
between accuracy and storytelling. Almost without exception,
the decisions made enhanced the tale. Even more important, the
inaccuracies that are present maintain the flavor of the Wallace
legend - the events might have happened this way.
The film opens with Wallace as a boy. Right
from the beginning we are shown that these Scots are a tough
people. When Wallace and another boy are playing war, they are
just as happy to slug it out with each other as they are with
throwing stones at the imaginary enemy. Parents likely dealt
with as many broken noses as they did skinned knees.
Wallace's family is brutally murdered by the
English and Wallace is sent away to live with an Uncle. This
Uncle, a terrifying image of a battle scarred old warrior, proves
to be a great influence to Wallace. He is educated in more than
just the use of a sword and passes on his knowledge to Wallace.
Wallace returns to his village as an adult
and resumes a romance with a childhood sweetheart. The budding
romance is kept secret partly because the girl's parents don't
fully approve (they see Wallace as a troublemaker, unwilling
to settle down) and partly because Longshanks, the King of England,
has imposed a First Night policy upon the Scots. In an effort
to pollute the Scottish bloodline, an English soldier is permitted
the first night, and all that implies, with any new Scottish
bride.
Unwilling to participate in this practice,
Wallace marries his sweetheart in secret. The English soldiers
suspect the truth, however, and demand their right from Wallace's
bride. She resists them and is put to death. This ignites a
fire within Wallace that won't be extinguished by anything less
than England's withdrawal from Scotland. He uses his passion
and anger to stir up his countrymen and incite a revolution.
Watching the film, one can easily appreciate
how difficult a time Mel Gibson must have had playing the part
of William Wallace. Not only is it a physically demanding role,
but it's also an emotional roller coaster. It's also easy to
appreciate how difficult a movie of this scale must have been
to direct. That Gibson also tackled that side of it makes this
film a monumental achievement due to the fact that he hits all
the right notes on both sides of the camera.
Aside from the superb performances by everyone
involved, this film also looks fantastic. We find out in Gibson's
commentary that much of the film's look was nearly accidental
(it rained so much that they had no choice but to shoot in it),
but it doesn't matter. Whether planned or not, every shot lends
to the epic scope of the film.
Braveheart's battle scenes get talked about
a lot and they deserve every bit of praise heaped upon them.
Every time I see the film, I'm amazed that such vividly realistic
battles could be depicted without really killing off half of
the extras. I know that there is a lot less violence actually
onscreen than what we think we see. It's a testament to the
filming, editing and choreography that those scenes come across
as utterly convincing as they do.
As I said, the DVD release of the film was
highly anticipated. It's my understanding that Paramount delayed
its initial plans for the disc until Gibson's schedule allowed
for him to record a commentary track. It's efforts such as that
one that make a DVD release special. This isn't a crammed special
edition, but it's good stuff nonetheless.