Filming a movie must be one of life's most
surreal experiences. Admittedly, I don't have any first-hand
knowledge of this, but let's consider the facts: You have a
group of people who are all pretending to be other people; most
films are shot out of sequence; finally, most films are either
pure fantasy or chronicle the most extreme aspects of the human
drama.
No wonder actors, directors, screenwriters
and other filmmakers are a strange lot.
And yet, strangeness does not even begin to
describe Adaptation, the latest effort from screenwriter Charlie
Kaufman. This is the sort of film that defies explanation and
exists within its own genre.
The story behind the film, and the story within
it, for that matter, is that Kaufman was given the job of adapting
Susan Orlean's book The Orchid Thief into a film. When most
writers have problems with their story, they struggle, anguish
and if they're lucky, come up with a solution. When Kaufman
has troubles, he decides to abandon the normal practice of adapting
a book and instead writes a story about his struggles in writing
a story.
The film opens with Charlie Kaufman (Nicholas
Cage) in a meeting with his agent. He is being given the assignment
to adapt The Orchid Thief. He knows nothing of orchids and is
immediately aware that the book was far outside of his usual
writing talents, but he is too timid to do anything but accept
the assignment.
Charlie's troubles begin almost immediately
as he reads through the book and discovers that there is very
little there to form the story for a movie. Making matters worse
is Charlie's twin brother, Donald (also played by Cage and one
of the few fictional characters in the film). Donald has become
obsessed with screenwriting and has fallen under the spell of
Robert McKee, the king of formula script writing. Donald's enthusiasm
for get-rich-quick screenwriting only adds to Charlie's frustrations.
It doesn't help when Donald eventually sells his by-the-numbers
script.
Inter cut with Charlie's struggles is the
story of Susan Orlean (Meryl Streep) and her adventures and
budding infatuation with the orchid thief of her book, John
Laroche (Chris Cooper). Laroche is a man spiraling downward
after a tragic accident cost him his family. His current scheme
is to hire Native Americans to help him pick orchids from a
preserve in Florida that also happens to be ancestral Native
American land.
Despite the fact that Laroche is, in many
ways, a highly despicable and unpleasant man, Orlean finds herself
inexplicably attracted to him.
Eventually, bordering on desperation, Charlie
asks Donald to help him write the screenplay. It's at this point
that the story begins to go from strange to surreal. You can
almost see the switching of gears in the film from Charlie's
emphasis on storytelling to Donald's obsession with formula.
And yet, even when the film is playing by the standard Hollywood
rules, there is nothing standard about the various twists and
turns of events.
I watch hundreds of films a year and many
of them are bland and forgettable. Even most of the good films
tend to follow predictable plot lines. It is refreshing, then,
to watch a film filled with genuine surprises. Adaptation is
original and ingenious and Charlie Kaufman has hooked me. I
want to see more by him.